Showing posts with label Matthew 25: 31-46. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Matthew 25: 31-46. Show all posts

Saturday, 6 April 2019

Strange Stories:Judgement


The passage we heard this morning has often been taken to mean, do the right thing and see Jesus in each other, because you will be judged individually based on your behaviour.
I think it is a little more complex than that.

Maybe where this fits into Matthews gospel might give us some clues in thinking about this passage.

The entry of Jesus into Jerusalem that we will hear next Sunday, Palm Sunday, is in chapter 21 – there is a whole lot that Matthew includes as happening in the few days between the triumphant entry and the betrayal, arrest, trial and crucifixion.  

Matthew includes
  • the cleansing of the temple,
  • lament over Jerusalem
  • prophecy of the destruction temple,
  • persecution

  • questions about
    • paying taxes
    • resurrection
    • the greatest commandment

  • parables of
    • the wicked tenants,
    • the wedding banquet,
    • ten bridesmaids
    • talents

After this story of judgement,
  • plot to kill Jesus
  • Jesus is anointed
  • Passover
  • Garden of Gethsemane
  • etc.

Early in chapter 24, the disciples ask Jesus: “What will be the sign of your coming and of the end of the world?”  Matthew 24:3 CEV; Matthew then writes about persecution and suffering, the need to be ready, including the parables you heard last week, then this reading about judgement. After this passage, we hear of the plot to kill Jesus, the anointing of Jesus at Bethany, then the Passover.

We are at the pointy end of the gospel.  



Jesus could read the signs around him, he knew the religious and political authorities were not happy, he knew he could be arrested or killed at any time. During these few days, Jesus did a lot of teaching, responded to questions, and told some stories, including the parables we looked at in the past 2 weeks, and the story we heard this morning.  

One way of looking at this reading is to think of the connection with the arrest, trial and crucifixion of Jesus.[i]
  • on the cross he is thirsty – who gives him something to drink? [27:34, 27:48] soldiers, bystanders
  • his clothes are taken from him – who covers his nakedness [27:59] Joseph of Arimathea
  • how was he treated in prison [27:27-37]
  • was Jesus welcomed, or treated as a stranger [26:70] Peter denies knowing Jesus; the crowd [27: 21 – 23]

Shortly, Jesus is the one who will be thirsty and naked and imprisoned. Does this change how we read this story?
….

One thing to note with this passage is that neither those who fed and clothed and visited, nor those who did not feed and clothe and visit, knew that they were or were not serving Jesus.

The ones labelled sheep, did not care and visit and provide shelter because they knew this would earn them favour in God’s eyes. They did it because that was what they naturally did. They were caring and compassionate.
Same with those labelled goats, they were living in ways that were natural to them, looking after their own interests and not being concerned about others. [ii]

Neither saw the King in need, the goats would have helped if they had seen him hungry or lonely. The sheep helped even though they did not recognise the King in those they served. They simply saw people who needed to be fed or clothed or visited or respected.
Those who were sheep, saw people as people. [iii]  
People made in the image of God.
People worthy of respect.
People for whom Jesus died. [iv]

In a culture where the social code was that you only helped those who could later repay you, or where you would be rewarded in some way, helping those who cannot repay you is foolish, even shameful. The sheep ignored the social code.[v]

This isn’t about doing the right thing to be saved.

This is about transformation of our lives from the inside, from our hearts and minds, so that the care and compassion we show others is not only genuine but natural. It is not forced to earn brownie points from God.

….

As I said earlier this passage is often understood in terms of individual behaviour. In some of my reading this week, it was noted that the judgement is of the nations, it is not an individual judgement that is being spoken of here, but a judgement of nations, countries, empires.

What if we look at this with the eyes of a first century Palestinian, living in a country occupied by Rome. What if this parable is about judging the politics and economics of empires? In many regimes, life is cheap, toe the line or else life will be difficult.

If this is about judging nations, or empires, how would Australia be judged? A single person on Newstart allowance receives $ 555.70 per fortnight, the cheapest rent on the peninsula is $270 per week, or $540 per fortnight. With rent assistance that leaves $152.90 left to live on for 2 weeks.

From the beginning, “Creation has been structured by God to work best for everyone, “all the nations,” when the most vulnerable are attended to instead of the least vulnerable.”[vi]

….

I don’t know anyone who likes the idea of being judged, especially with criteria like these. We don’t want to let God down. [vii] It seems impossible.

But this is Good News, maybe not for us, but for those who are hungry and in prison. How might we hear this if we lived in North Korea? How might we have heard this if we had been imprisoned in Nazi Germany?  Might this be Good News, that God will not allow injustice and suffering to go unpunished. That ‘God cares passionately about the suffering of the least of these, and about whether we cause or ignore it -- so much so that Jesus bore this suffering in his own body in order to triumph over evil and death.’ [viii]
….

The two greatest commandments are loving God and loving neighbour. This parable speaks into the living out of those commandments.  
As individuals and in community, remembering that the compassion of the sheep was the not rehearsed or planned, it was the natural outworking of their relationship with God. They saw people as people,
·         they fed the hungry,
·         welcomed the stranger
·         clothed the naked
·         cared for the sick
·         visited the imprisoned
not because they deserved it or earned it,
not because they were friends or family.
The sheep acted with compassion because of the transformation of their lives.



[ii] https://www.workingpreacher.org/preaching.aspx?commentary_id=3872
[iii] https://provokingthegospel.wordpress.com/2017/11/20/a-provocation-reign-of-christ-sunday-november-26-2017-matthew-2531-46/?fbclid=IwAR2gNLzO4hPi8CHZm2Yg_4u5pL-JoenZltXYVgsLO2FmzVnD7vbTTY_0K4s
[iv] http://girardianlectionary.net/reflections/year-a/xrstkinga/?fbclid=IwAR09pP4H2czZMWnCTSlZsmEWsaw26nw6zvEvzFY6iMQS-SqMHHX7TYWPddo
[vi]http://girardianlectionary.net/reflections/year-a/xrstkinga/?fbclid=IwAR09pP4H2czZMWnCTSlZsmEWsaw26nw6zvEvzFY6iMQS-SqMHHX7TYWPddo
[vii] https://revgalblogpals.org/2019/04/02/narrative-lectionary-sheep-and-goats-matt-2531-46/?fbclid=IwAR1DAPzUIE0Ox7dTZVj5bYF8mB7xCteJEqZjqrou8ZlMlfQUsolAULoNxMk
[viii] https://www.workingpreacher.org/preaching.aspx?commentary_id=3872

Saturday, 21 March 2015

Judgement


This section of Matthew’s gospel is usually read on Christ the King Sunday, so it seems unusual to hear it read towards the end of Lent.  If we look at where Matthew includes this story. The entry of Jesus into Jerusalem that we will hear next Sunday, Palm Sunday, is in chapter 21 – there is a whole lot that Matthew includes as happening in the few days between the triumphant entry and the betrayal, arrest, trial and crucifixion.  

 

Matthew includes

  • the cleansing of the temple,
  • lament over Jerusalem
  • prophecy of the destruction temple,
  • persecution

  •  questions about
    • paying taxes
    • resurrection
    • the greatest commandment

 parables of
    • the wicked tenants,
    • the wedding banquet,
    • ten bridesmaids
    • talents
After this story of judgement,

  • plot to kill Jesus
  • Jesus is anointed
  • Passover
  • Garden of Gethsemane
  • etc.

 Jesus could read the signs around him, he knew the religious and political authorities were not happy, he knew he could be arrested or killed at any time. During these few days, Jesus did a lot of teaching,  responded to questions, and told some stories, including the parables we looked at in the past 2 weeks, and the story we heard this morning.  

 

One way of looking at this reading is to think of the connection with the arrest, trial and crucifixion of Jesus. Jesus is about to be thirsty, naked and scorned.[i]

  • on the cross he is thirsty – who gives him something to drink? [27:34, 27:48] soldiers, bystanders
  • his clothes are taken from him – who covers his nakedness [27:59] Joseph of Arimathea
  • how was he treated in prison [27:27-37]
  • was Jesus welcomed, or treated as a stranger [26:70] Peter denies knowing Jesus; the crowd [27: 21 – 23]

 ………………

Another way to understand this story is to think about where we fit – are we sheep or goats? Remember both groups were surprised, the sheep weren’t helping because they were going to be judged, but because people were hungry or thirsty or cold.  And the goats weren’t snubbing the King, if they knew it was him, of course they would have helped.  This story encourages us to not focus on ourselves, and what we will get out of feeding, clothing, or welcoming someone; but to focus on the person who is hungry, lonely or scared.

Not an easy thing to do.

 

But there is a twist in the story - the social code of the time meant that you only helped those who could later repay you, or where you would be rewarded in some way. The sheep ignored the social code.[ii]

The goats behaved in a way that society accepted, the sheep were foolish.

…………

 

Another thing with this parable, as with some others, is that we tend to immediately assume that the King is God or Jesus – even when that figure in the story behaves differently to everything we know about Jesus from the rest of the gospel.[iii]

This passage is the only place in Matthews gospel that has the phrase ‘eternal punishment’ and there is only one other reference to ‘eternal fire’. [18:8]

 

What if this isn’t God, or Jesus, judging the nations;  I wonder who the judge might be?

  

And really

is any nation,

or group of people,

or individual,

always helping those who need help,

or never helping those who need help.

Let’s face it, most people, and nations, are both sheep and goats at the same time.

 

how would you judge?

how would you decide who goes to eternal punishment and who to eternal life?

 

I know that isn’t our judgement to make it,

but how often do we make those judgements?

 

How often does our judgment make life hell for someone else? or for yourself?

 

a few weeks ago I showed a picture, the caption was  “The only time you should look in your Neighbour’s bowl is to make sure they have enough. You don’t look in your neighbour’s bowl to see if you have … as much as them.” [iv]


What if the judgement is ours?

because the more we focus on our own life, our own needs, our own worthiness – the less secure we are in our own life, the more we worry about having enough, about being good enough, clever enough, pretty enough. And comparing ourselves to others.

 

What happens when we focus on the needs of others,

  • when we offer food and drink and clothing to people, not because we think they deserve it, but because they are hungry and thirsty and cold
  • what happens when we welcome, include  and encourage  people; not because we like them, but because they are lonely and isolated and looked down upon.
  • what happens when we share, when we welcome, when we visit - when we no longer worry about being good enough.



When our life is no longer focussed on ourselves?

 

What if eternal punishment is what happens when we focus on our own needs, and ignore the cries of the hungry, lonely and imprisoned.